1. Feedback Is Not Neutral
When someone gives feedback during climbing, it immediately affects:
- cognitive load
- attention focus
- prediction stability
- emotional arousal
- decision clarity
- movement timing
Poor feedback increases noise.
Good feedback reduces noise.
The goal of communication is not motivation.
It is clarity without overload.
2. The Three Feedback Errors That Ruin Performance
Error 1 — Too Much Information
Example:
“Right hand higher, left foot lower, rotate more, don’t forget the undercling, then match, then high step.”
Result:
- overload
- hesitation
- delayed timing
- tension increase
The brain cannot process multiple corrections mid-move.
Error 2 — Vague Instructions
Example:
“Trust it.”
“Commit.”
“Just go.”
These increase emotional arousal but provide zero mechanical clarity.
Error 3 — Timing Interference
Shouting feedback during dynamic moves disrupts motor timing and creates hesitation.
Timing is fragile.
Interruption breaks execution.
3. The Golden Rule of Climbing Feedback
Reduce uncertainty. Do not add new decisions.
Every piece of feedback must:
- simplify
- clarify
- narrow options
- stabilise rhythm
If feedback adds complexity, it harms performance.
THE COMMUNICATION PROTOCOL
Use this structure for all partner/coach interaction.
PHASE 1 — Pre-Climb Feedback (Maximum Value Zone)
This is where 90% of useful feedback belongs.
Rules:
- Keep it short.
- One correction at a time.
- Specific mechanical instruction only.
- No emotional commentary.
Good examples:
- “Right foot higher.”
- “Turn your hip left.”
- “Use the thumb.”
- “Breathe before the dyno.”
- “Match before moving.”
Clear. Mechanical. Executable.
PHASE 2 — During-Climb Feedback (Minimal Zone)
Only give feedback during climbing if:
- safety is involved
- the climber requested a cue
- the cue is pre-agreed
Allowed cues:
- “Breathe.”
- “Left foot.”
- “Now.”
One word. No analysis.
Anything more creates cognitive overload.
PHASE 3 — Post-Climb Feedback (Analysis Zone)
This is where real development happens.
Structure:
- Ask the climber what they felt.
- Compare perception to reality.
- Identify one correction.
- Create a simple execution plan.
Do not give 5 corrections.
One correction → repeat attempt → integrate → move on.
Learning happens through repetition, not lectures.
4. How Feedback Increases Cognitive Load
When you receive feedback, your brain must:
- process instruction
- adjust motor prediction
- update timing
- suppress previous plan
- increase attention
That costs bandwidth.
If cognitive load is already high (hard climb),
extra instructions reduce execution quality.
5. The “One Variable Rule”
Only adjust one variable per attempt.
Variables include:
- foot placement
- hip direction
- timing
- breathing
- grip orientation
- sequence order
Change one.
Test.
Observe.
Then change the next.
This preserves motor stability.
6. Emotional Language vs Mechanical Language
Emotional language:
- “You got this.”
- “Don’t be scared.”
- “Trust yourself.”
- “Be aggressive.”
These increase arousal but do not improve movement.
Mechanical language:
- “Rotate left hip.”
- “Stand up on the right foot.”
- “Pause before bump.”
- “Exhale and go.”
These improve prediction accuracy.
Mechanical language builds stable performance.
7. Communication in Competition
Competition demands extreme communication discipline.
Before attempt:
- confirm sequence
- confirm crux
- confirm rhythm
- confirm commitment point
During attempt:
- silence unless safety issue
- one-word cues only
After attempt:
- brief analysis
- one correction
- next attempt
Anything else adds noise.
8. Outdoor Communication Differences
Outdoor climbing often increases fear and uncertainty.
Communication should:
- reduce ambiguity
- clarify footholds
- confirm safe fall zones
- confirm protection
But avoid shouting multiple instructions mid-crux.
Outdoor noise + verbal overload = chaos.
9. Receiving Feedback Properly
The climber also has responsibility.
When receiving feedback:
- don’t defend
- don’t overthink
- don’t reinterpret
- apply exactly once
- evaluate after
You are testing prediction models, not debating opinions.
10. The Feedback Stability Loop
Good communication creates this loop:
Clarity →
Reduced uncertainty →
Lower cognitive load →
Better movement →
Better outcome →
Higher confidence →
More clarity
Bad communication creates the opposite.
11. Signs Feedback Is Hurting You
- you hesitate more
- you overthink mid-move
- your rhythm breaks
- you feel tense
- you second-guess decisions
- you climb worse than alone
Reduce feedback immediately.
12. Key Insight
Communication is not about encouragement.
It is about reducing cognitive load and improving prediction accuracy.
Good feedback:
- is short
- is specific
- is mechanical
- is timed correctly
- changes one variable
- improves clarity
When communication becomes precise, climbing becomes predictable.